There seems to be a common view that the days of the professional journalist are numbered, as publishers can rely on content created by their users to fill the pages of their magazines and websites, reducing costs.
I personally don’t believe this will be the case, and hopefully I can now explain why. It’s something that does personally affect me, being a professional editorial person, but that doesn’t mean I’m precious about my position.
Many staff writers will be replaced by user generated content. There will be a need for someone to provide editorial judgement over the quality of each submission, but there will be a reduced need for writers.
However, that ignores the fact that the users submitting content will increasingly expect to get paid. Thereby creating a new profession of freelance staff who have no ties to companies or subjects, but will be able to float around the internet as a migrant workforce.
Increasingly the top web sites will be required to increase wages for the most prominent users, to retain their submissions, and this will in effect replace a staff of paid writers with…. a staff of paid writers…
The only implications I can see are that the staff of a website will be far more disparate and spread throughout the world, and that there will be problems for journalistic training bodies in a few years. After all, why would you spend three years on a degree to move into the media, when you could be blogging from 16 for the same results. The only people who will be requiring training will be the sub-editors selecting quality levels and editing copy to meet a minimum standard of literacy.
The only shock I can see for most people will be the split between the value of a brand, and the value of individual writers. If individual submitters are perceived to have a value as high as a magazine brand, then there is nothing to stop them branching out within an hour of making that decision.
In fact, for the top nth percent, it could soon be a licence to print money. If you have built up an audience submiting articles to a major brand, you can quite easily go and blog elswhere, or spread you work around, and your audience will soon find you on a search engine. It will also be interesting to see how many users are willing to hand over their copyrights, as more and more people look at earning a wage from online submissions.

There’s no reason to think expert content has no value in the future; there’s every reason to think no one has deployed it correctly yet. I posted as much in the last couple of weeks over on fasterfuture.
I think the net result for everyone of UGC is that we all get (eventually, following your logic) much better, more focused writing with proper experts in their fields who also happen to be able to engage.
I’m not convinced of the need for editors in the long run given the community’s potential to rate and self-police.
My only concern for that is the old chestnut of the tyranny of democracy. ie a lot of people might vote for the death penalty – but it don’t make it right.
But communities are likely to form around ideas, shared beliefs and shared problem solving. Take that view and what they want is king.
I don’t think that UGC is the opposite of expert content. I do think that every example of community rating has so far been exploited either by self-interest, or has so far given prominence to information which isn’t reliable.
The number of problems with stories being rated highly on Digg for example, or problems with Wikipedia entries.
The community as one group want to be able to make themselves famous etc, but they also want to be able to find reliable opinions and advice. And if they are no longer tied-in to brands as their source for advice, then they’ll tie in to other individuals, who then become equivalent to a staff writer etc on a current print magazine.
To use a practical example.
Currently MCN has a news desk with a News Editor and around 6 News Reporters.
Take away the print product, and you have no need for anyone below the News Editor level.
And rather than running his 6 reporters, he’ll instead be responsible for organising the contributions of the most trusted content submitters.
Meanwhile the staff writer/reporter type jobs will disapear. Instead, individuals will be submitting articles to MCN, and several other places, depending on how much they can get paid, and what copyright restrictions are in place. And it will be hard to restrict writers who can publish their stories throughout a worldwide range of rivals.
At first the idea of only paying for results, and not needing a huge office etc is pretty attractive from a financial viewpoint. But what will it cost to ensure any reliability from the most prominent submitters, and how much will it cost to ensure they break news on our site first?