• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
TheWayoftheWeb

TheWayoftheWeb

Content and Digital Marketing Specialists

  • Blog
  • The Cipher
  • About Us
    • Useful Resources For Businesses In Peterborough, UK
  • Contact Us
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Digital Culture

Creative flow?

March 6, 2009 By Dan Thornton

I recently watched an interesting TED presentation by Elizabeth Gilbert on ‘a new way to think about creativity’ (found via Lateral Action where there’s a good post about the content of the talk):

The presentation looks at how creativity was often assigned to divine assistance in historical times, and the benefits that approach had – and could still have.

And examples include dancers in Spain, who for one night might be seen as channelling that divine creativity, or an American poet who felt like she had to catch poems as they passed her by.

But the insight that people, including Gilbert, can work for a long time before having that moment of celebrated divine creativity struck a chord, and reminded me of another interesting TED talk:

It also ties into the idea of practice, and of 10,000 hours being about right for expertise in any field, as written about recently in Outliers: The Story of Success. (My own thoughts on Outliers)

As a writer/journalist/blogger/marketer/geek,  I’m always fascinated by insights into creativity and expertise – Lateral Action has proved a constant source of great insight, along with Springwise and many more sites (Many of them appear in my Google Reader Shared Items). All accompanied by music – usually Last.fm.

It did bring up one question on a marketing theme – with so many new social networks arriving, and so many new social media marketing experts appearing – how many people can honestly claim to be approaching 10,000 hours working in social media marketing or especially on a single social network?

Ben Goldacre provides perspective on ‘Facebook cancer’ claims

February 27, 2009 By Dan Thornton

This clip should probably become standard issue for anyone who is in a panic over the latest newspaper headlines concerning health – and particularly for anyone talking or thinking about the latest concerns about Twitter and Facebook:

Helpfully, Dr Goldacre has posted the papers and research he referenced on the Bad Science blog,  and there’s some very interesting reading – well worth knowing for anyone who works with social media and social networks for any future debates.

(I already posted responses from the NHS and The Guardian’s Charles Arthur, plus my own response to the Sigman paper)

Clip found at Johnnie Moore‘s Weblog, apparently from David Smith‘s Delicious feed.

Responses to ‘social network health threat’ include the NHS

February 20, 2009 By Dan Thornton

Following the mass media coverage of Aric Sigman’s paper on the ‘biological implications of social networking’, to which I added my own response yesterday, the Institute of Biology has made the paper publicly available.

And there are two good responses to reading the paper available already, and well worth reading.

The first is by Charles Arthur on the Guardian technology blog, which is a pretty fair and balanced look at the paper.

And the second is a great examination of the findings by the National Health Service Choices site. (Cheers to @peeebeee for the tip)

Both point out that the description of the paper and the subsequent reporting appears to have made a jump from the actual research into the implications of isolation, to claiming that social networking is causing isolation without any evidence.

‘A Facebook poke cannot replace a good old hug, it seems.’  – from the Insititue of Biology’s own description.

I don’t think anyone would claim replacing physical contact with humans with digital contact exclusively would be a desirable aim – which is probably why so many online social networks are devoted to enabling people to connect and then meet in the real world – Facebook events, online dating, barcamps, unconferences, travel networks etc.

For instance, I love the latest blog post from travel network Dopplr – highlighting that there were 250,000+ times travellers were coincidentally in the same place and could have shared dinner etc.

I don’t think the debate about the potential health risks (physical and mental) of changing work and leisure should be dismissed or hidden. I just fear that, as often happens, the sensible debate gets buried under soundbites to the point that any realistic recommendations are ignored because people have become tired of the subject.

Are social networks really killing us…

February 19, 2009 By Dan Thornton

I happened to catch an item on television featuring Aric Sigman, who was talking about his paper on the ‘biological implications of social networking’, or, as every media appearance has titled it – how social networks are killing us. Online Networks ‘harm health’ in the case of the BBC.

Sadly his paper is behind a paid firewall, so I can only go by what was covered during the television interviews/online reporting, and from his writing available via a quick google search.

Interestingly, one of the major topics that turns up is the TV ‘rots the brain and ruins the body. We should see TV for what it is – the biggest public health threat of our time.’ (writing for The Guardian). He’s also written a book on that topic: Remotely Controlled: How Television is Damaging Our Lives.

As someone who evangelises about the positive effects of social networks and online collaboration, you might expect me to try and dismiss everything he claims, and adhere to the blogging stereotype.

But that’s impossible without being able to look at his work, and sources, in-depth.

And there are certain elements of it which make sense.

For example, he writes about protecting children online requiring real-time parental control, with which I’d agree.  The biggest safeguard from the supposed threat of online predators is not allowing the use of webcams except in public family spaces, for example.

And there’s certainly a wealth of evidence on the topics of television, film and videogame influence on children.  And certainly there are health risks to doing anything to excess, such as spending hours with the TV, PC or game console. Conversely, cutting out all human face-to-face interaction also has an obvious effect on people.

But there are elements of his approach that really, really, bother me.

Firstly, technology always carries a health risk with it – the Industrial Revolution, the ability to move faster than walking speed, the ability to hurtle through the air in a big tin can all carry risks – over time the risks can be reduced, but as a whole we accept them as being something to accommodate or ignore.

So rather than lobby for abstaining from using tools which are way past mass adoption, would it not be more productive to find ways that the benefits could be increased and the risks decreased?

Secondly: Dr Sigman quotes research that shows since 1987 face-to-face interaction has fallen dramatically as electronic media has risen. That much is obvious – but linking that to individuals becoming more isolated seems predicated on the image of the isolated loner on the computer in a dark room.

For example, what effect have different working practices had? Home working for example? Or the increase in geographical moves away from family and friends? Or different family units?

Thirdly: Television and the internet can replace offline social interaction – but can also facilitate it. For many, being able to arrange events via Facebook and Twitter has had a positive effect on social interaction. For example, meeting new people in 175+ cities for Twestival. Or a host of gatherings, unconferences and barcamps.  I wish I could find out how the information was gathered which tells us people spend less time interacting in person since they joined social networks.

It’s interesting that he’s quoted saying:

“”In less than two decades, the number of people saying there is no-one with whom they discuss important matters nearly tripled.”

Really?

Can’t be very important to them, then.

I’ve had fantastic discussions about things incredibly important to me that were only possible by being connected to friends and family via the internet, and if anything, the opportunities for those discussions have multiplied to the extent that I have to limit my time to get things done!

And without access to television or the internet, I’d have far more limited opportunities to interact around common topics.

Lastly: Apparently this could all result in anything from altering the way genes work to cancer, strokes and dementia. Without access to the original material I can only assume that the BBC use of terms like ‘evidence suggests” and ‘he claims’ might mean the link has yet to be conclusively proven.

Don’t give me problems: When he suggests limited the access a child has to television or the internet, it can realistically work. But for many people, the use of a computer for 8 hours a day is part of their career, and no-one would sanction replacing an office of computers with typewriters in the hope people will interact more and be healthier.

Here’s an idea:

Rather than being the problem, maybe social networks (including mobile) are actually the start of the solution.

They encourage communication, collaboration and meeting.

They give rise to events, and enable groups of people to meet quickly and easily.

They allow people to find other individuals with a shared interest and build a community around it.

They replace time spent sedentary in front of a television, which halts discussion, and can be used to encourage activity.

There are lots of examples of people coming together, particularly around sport. Maybe we should be encouraging those?

Bit of a lengthy, ranty post, but if you’ve made it this far – thoughts? comments? Am I the only person who finds a new Event invite every day on Facebook?

Why Twitter won’t replace Google search- but will overtake it

February 16, 2009 By Dan Thornton

The reason why Twitter and real-time information will overtake Google search isn’t because of the aggregation of the ‘Thought stream’ as Techcrunch has proposed, as Lew Moorman has written, or even as Robert Scoble has written.

For some reason, we still think that a new service will totally replace the old, and that the two compete on the same field, even though Robert’s post alluded to where I see the real advantage for real-time information.

Google provides signposts for where you want to go. Twitter provides you with a guided tour by your friends.

It’s not about searching the aggregate of real-time information.

It’s about asking the members of your network in real-time for responses.

And it’s about increasingly moving towards Vendor Relationship Management, rather than Customer Relationship Management.

I don’t care as much about the general consensus of the population of Twitter about a subject as often as I care about the opinions of the core group of my 2300 followers on the specific question I’ve posed.

And that’s where the threat to Google occurs. As a normal Twitter user, I’ll occasionally look at what the general populace reports around breaking news or a major event. But it’s the closer network within my followers who provide the real value of responding in minutes, or even seconds, to my requests and questions.

It allows people (and one day, perhaps companies), to come to me with the information I need, rather than setting out on my own to try to navigate my way to what I need.

Real-time web allows me to ask for information and have it brought to me by my core group of contacts and relevant people/companies. That’s the real-time benefit – not in evolving search.

But this doesn’t mean that there is no need for search.

Guided Tours by friends don’t remove the need for signposts, for example when friends aren’t available.

I’m already finding that I use search far, far less than ever before.

Real time search is only really valuable when there is a need to guage public opinion for businesses, marketeers, journalists, writers etc. (the last two refer to print, web, blog, tv, radio, mobile).

So trust me to choose search, questioning friends, or real-time search when it’s appropriate for what I want to do, and don’t rip up all the singposts in case I don’t know anyone in a particular town!

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 3
  • Page 4
  • Page 5
  • Page 6
  • Page 7
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 14
  • Go to Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

Join us…

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

We only exist to deliver results for your business. So you get fresh Content, expert SEO, engaging Social Media, or a new Website which is right for you – and your customers.

We help you build your brand, reach more customers and increase your revenue

Search

Categories

Creative Commons License
This work by TheWayoftheWeb is provided under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Start growing your business today Contact Us

Recent Comments

  • Don't wait for your ship to come in... - TheWayoftheWeb on Freelance & Consultancy

TheWayoftheWeb

Copyright © 2026· TheWayoftheWeb Ltd. Company Number 08038527. ICO registration: ZB397650