I’m the first to criticise advertising for generally being ineffectual rubbish, but sometimes on a very rare occasion, it grabs me – the new advert for The Guardian succeeds on pretty much every level I can think of for a television/video advert. It’s entertaining, unusual and thought-provoking.
OK, it doesn’t provide utility, but that would be quite hard to tie into the concept, and there are some small additional elements online to support the advert.
Instant classic, and also capitalizing on recent events whether it’s the economic climate, Occupy etc. OK, advertising industry, you won this time…
Interestingly, the official Youtube version has only had 309 views since being uploaded at some point on February 29th (I don’t know when exactly it was uploaded, but it’s under 24 hours ago). And they do manage a minor blot of their copybook by prefacing a highly sharable advert for their product with generic Youtube advertising for 30 seconds beforehand. So there’s still a little room for improvement!

This is a great ad and worthy of praise but i think you’re being a bit harsh to say advertisibg is largely inneffectual. its not a problem with advertising but a problem.with the creativity of the adverts. I can name a lot of adverts that are both memorable and improve the image of the brands, many if which have been huge successes online as well. The trou le is there is also a lot of bad advertising that actually leaves you thinking worse of the brand. How this kind of creative ever gets signed off is beyond me.
OK – I’d be interested if you want to list as many interesting, memorable adverts that not only improved the image of the brand, but also led to business/purchases.
T-Mobile Flashmob, VW Vader, Old Spice guy, Evian Babies, Skoda cake…and thats just off the top of my head
Cheers ‘Gus, but I know you haven’t bought a Skoda, and I don’t remember you smelling of Old Spice.
😉
Seriously, they’re some interesting examples – I’d be intrigued to know how they’ve affected sales, but they do stand out (Although the use of Star Wars in advertising has had a negative effect on my perception of Star Wars, Vodaphone and PC World, as I’ve previously written).
But that’s 5 off-the-top of your head examples. I’ve had a quick look for UK stats, but the average American sees around 3000 ad messages per day. Assuming a bit of repetition, let’s knock that down to 10k a week.
So even if all those 6 had appeared in the same week, that’s 9994 that aren’t memorable, and are just being churned out by companies because ‘that’s what we’ve always done’, and ‘that’s what worked in the past’, or ‘well, our competitors advertised’, or ‘it makes us feel good to see a big TV ad or something in print’.
Compared to how the money could have been invested in better, more productive efforts with a more demonstratable return on investment.